When Your Toddler Dislikes the Babysitter

Help your toddler warm up to the babysitter with these steps.

3 min read · a quick one you can memorize

Jump Right In: Easing the Babysitter Transition

You've just hired a new babysitter, hoping for a quiet evening out, but your toddler's tears say otherwise. First things first, avoid joining the chorus of 'it's just a phase' nonsense. Instead, tackle it head-on.

Start by introducing the babysitter during a calm moment of the day, not when you're rushing to leave. Try the morning, perhaps after breakfast, when your toddler is usually in a better mood (coffee should have kicked in for everyone by then). Let them spend time together while you subtly supervise. This reduces the shock of being suddenly left alone with someone they're not used to.

Why Toddlers React This Way

Changing caregivers can be tough for toddlers. They thrive on routine and familiarity. When a new face appears, it might feel like their world is flipping. It's not just about the person being new but about the shift in their tiny, predictable universe.

Words and Actions: Making It Easier

  1. The Familiarity Hack: Have the babysitter bring a familiar toy or book from your home. "Hey little one, look what I brought — your favorite block from last time!" This small touch can bridge the gap between stranger and friend.

  2. Short Goodbyes: When you need to leave, make your goodbyes short and sweet. "I'm heading out, but I'll be back before your dinner of mac n' cheese," followed by a quick hug (avoiding the long tearful farewells that rival a soap opera).

  3. Set a Fun Activity: Arrange for the babysitter to do something your toddler loves right after you leave — whether it’s playing with their LEGO set or watching Paw Patrol. Fun can be a great distraction.

  4. Use Positive Language: Reinforce how much fun they'll have. "You're going to have so much fun with Emma today, she knows how to play that train game you like!"

How This Plays Out

In my own attempts (which sometimes fail — toddlers, right?), I've noticed that consistent sayings work wonders. For instance, telling my daughter, "Mom always comes back," during school drop-offs. She doesn't fully understand the deep philosophical meaning of those words, but repetition seems to comfort her.

Ending Note

No magical solution here, but consistency is key. Some kids just need a few calm experiences to adjust. Don't beat yourself up if it takes longer than planned. And if all else fails, maybe just plan for a pizza night in the living room — no babysitter needed for that.